ÀÛ¼ºÀÏ : 20-05-21 14:33
Çѱ¹ÀÇ º¸¼ö Á¤´çÀÇ Æ¯Â¡
 ±Û¾´ÀÌ : ÃÖ°í°ü¸®ÀÚ
Á¶È¸ : 12,820  


Çѱ¹ÀÇ º¸¼ö Á¤´çÀÇ Æ¯Â¡

ÀçÀÛ³â 9¿ù 30ÀÏ ÀÚ The Atlantic òµ´Â ¡° °øÈ­´ç, º¸¼öÁÖÀǸ¦ Æ÷±âÇÏ´Ù ¡° ´Â Á¦ÇÏ¿¡ Eliot Cohen ( Johns Hopkins Univ. Dean ) ÀÇ ±ÛÀ» ½Ç¾ú´Ù. ³»°¡ Cohen ÀÇ ±ÛÀ» ¾ð±ÞÇÑ ÀÌÀ¯´Â ±×°¡ Dictum À̶ó°í ¼Ò°³ÇÏ´Â ±¸ÀýÀÌ ³»°¡ ÇÁ¶û½ºÀÇ Ã¥µé¿¡¼­ ¸¹ÀÌ º¸¾Ò´ø °ÍÀ̱⠶§¹®ÀÌ´Ù.
¡° If one is not of the left as a young person, one has no heart, and not of the right in middle age, one has no head.¡±  
ÀÌ ±Û¿¡¼­ Cohen Àº Æò»ý µ¿¾È °øÈ­´çÀÇ °¡Ä¡¿Í ¿øÄ¢À» ÁöÁöÇÏ¿´À¸³ª, °øÈ­´ç ( ¹Ì±¹ ) °ú º¸¼öÀû ½Å³ä °£ÀÇ ÌÁܬÀº ¿ÏÀüÇÏ°í µÇµ¹¸± ¼ö ¾ø´Â °ÍÀÌ µÇ¾ú´Ù°í Çß´Ù. ±×´Â ¶ÇÇÑ E. Burke ·ÎºÎÅÍ Kristol ¿¡ À̸£´Â »ç»ó°¡ µéÀ» Ī¼ÛÇÏ´Â µ¥¼­ ÀÚÁÖ ÀοëµÇ´Â Ã¥ÀÓ, ±Ý¿å, ÀÚ±âÅëÁ¦, Ã漺½É, ÀýÁ¦, ¸í¿¹, ÀΰÝ, ±×¸®°í ÀÚÁÖ¼ºÀ» ¾ð±ÞÇϸ鼭 ÀÌµé º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀÚµéÀº µµ´öÀû ¿øÄ¢ÀÇ À̸§À¸·Î ÀÚ½ÅÀ» ¼¼¿ì·Á´Âµ¥ ÀÚ±à½ÉÀ» °¡Áø »ç¶÷µéÀ̶ó°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.
±×´Â Trump ÀÇ ´ëÅë·É ´ç¼± ÀÌÈÄ °øÈ­´çÀ» Å»ÅðÇÏ°í Trump ´ëÅë·ÉÀÇ ´ë³»-¿Ü Á¤Ã¥À» ºñÆÇÇÏ¿´´Ù. ±×´Â Reagan ´ëÅë·É°ú Trump ´ëÅë·ÉÀÇ Á¤Ã¥À» ºñ±³Çϸ鼭, Trump ´ëÅë·ÉÀÌ ÀÔ¹ýºÎÀÇ ÀÔÀåÀ» °æ¸êÇϸ鼭 ÇàÁ¤ºÎ Áß½ÉÀûÀÎ Á¤Ã¥ ÁøÇàÀ» ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀ» ºñÆÇÇÏ°í ¹Ì±¹°ú µ¿¸Í±¹ °úÀÇ °ü°è, À̹ÎÀڵ鿡 ´ëÇÑ Â÷º°Àû Á¤Ã¥, µîÀ» ¿¹·Î µé¸é¼­ Reagan ´ëÅë·ÉÀÇ ´ë¿Ü °ü°è¿¡¼­ÀÇ °ü´ëÇÔ, ±¹³» Á¤Ä¡¿¡¼­ÀÇ ´ç´çÇÑ Á¤Ã¥ ÃßÁøÀ» ³ôÀÌ Æò°¡ÇÏ°í ÀÖ¾ú´Ù.
±×´Â ¹Ì±¹ Á¤Ä¡¿¡¼­ ³ë¿¹¹®Á¦ µî°ú °°Àº ¾îµÎ¿î ¸éÀÌ ÀÖ¾úÀ¸³ª, ÀÌÁ¦ ´Ù½Ã ±×·± °ÍµéÀÌ Çö½Ç¿¡¼­ ¿ªº´°ú °°Àº ¸ð½ÀÀ¸·Î µîÀåÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù°í Çϸ鼭, º¸¼öÀû Á¤´çÀ¸·Î¼­ °øÈ­´çÀÌ ´Ù½Ã º¹±¸Çϸ®¶ó´Â Àü¸ÁÀ» ºÎÀÎÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.
±×·¯³ª Taft, Buckley µîÀÇ ÁøÁ¤ÇÑ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀÚµéÀÌ µµ´ö¼ºÀÇ À̸§À¸·Î ÀÚ½ÅÀÇ ÀÔÀåÀ» ¼¼¿ì·Á´Â °Í°ú °°ÀÌ º¸¼öÀû Á¤´çÀÌ µîÀåÇÒ °ÍÀ» ¾ð±ÞÇϸ鼭µµ ±× ÁöµµÀÚÀÇ µîÀå°ú ±× ½Ã±â´Â ¶§¸¦ ±â´Ù·Á¾ß ÇÑ´Ù°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ¾ú´Ù.

Çѱ¹ º¸¼ö´çÀÇ ÂüÆÐ
ÃÖ±Ù ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ Á¤Ä¡Æò·Ð¿¡ ÀÚÁÖ µîÀåÇÏ´Â ¿ë¾î Áß¿¡ Oxymoron À̶ó´Â °ÍÀÌ ÀÖ´Ù. ¿¹¸¦ µéÀÚ¸é, Liberal °ú Conservative ¸¦ ¿¬°á½ÃŲ ´Ü¾î·Î ¾²¸é¼­ ÀÌ°ÍÀÌ Oxymoron ÀÌ ¾Æ´Ñ°¡ ÇÏ´Â Á¦¸ñÀ¸·Î Gleaves Whitney °¡ ¾´ ±ÛÀÌ ÀÖ´Ù.( Is a "Liberal Conservative" an Oxymoron?, 2019, 08.08 ) ÀÌ ÀÚÀ¯ÀûÀÎ °Í°ú º¸¼öÀûÀÎ °ÍÀº ¼­·Î ±× Àǹ̰¡ ¹Ýµå½Ã ¸ð¼øÀº ¾Æ´Ï¶óµµ ¼­·Î ´ë¸³µÇ´Â µÎ Á¤Ã¥Àû Àǹ̰¡ ÇϳªÀÇ ÅëÇÕµÈ ÀǹÌó·³ Ç¥ÇöµÇ´Â °ÍÀÌ ½ÇÁ¦·Î °¡´ÉÇÑ °ÍÀΰ¡ ÇÏ´Â Àǹ®À» ´øÁö°Ôµµ ÇÑ´Ù.
ÀÌ¹Ì ¿ª»çÀûÀ¸·Î º¸¼öÀûÀÎ Disraeli °¡ 1850³â ´ë¿¡ ÀÌ ¿ë¾î¸¦ »ç¿ëÇÏ¿´°í, ÃÖ±Ù¿¡ Çѱ¹¿¡¼­µµ ÀÌ ¿ë¾î¸¦ ¾ð±ÞÇÑ »ç¶÷ÀÌ ÀÖ¾ú´Ù. Á¤Ã¥ÀûÀ¸·Î ´ë¸³µÇ´Â Àǹ̷ΠÀÌÇصǴø, À̸¦ Å׸é, Áøº¸ÁÖÀÇÀÚµéÀÇ ÀÚÀ¯ÁÖÀÇÀû ÀÇ¹Ì¿Í º¸¼öÀû Á¤´çµéÀÇ º¸¼öÀû Á¤Ã¥ÀÌ °áÇÕÀ» ÇÑ ÇüÅ·Π³ªÅ¸³­ ÀÌ ¿ë¾î´Â 20¼¼±â ÀÌÈÄ·Î »çȸ º¹Áö Á¤Ã¥Àº ´õ ÀÌ»ó Áøº¸Àû, ÁÂÆÄÀÇ ÀüÀ¯¹°ÀÌ ¾Æ´Ï°í, ÀÇ·áÁ¦µµ¿¡ ´ëÇÑ º¸¼ö Á¤´çµéÀÇ Àû±ØÀû Á¤Ã¥À¸·Î ±¹¹ÎÀÇ È£ÀÀÀ» ¾òÀ¸·Á´Â ´ë»óÀÌ µÇ°Ô µÈ °Í¿¡¼­ ±× ÁÁÀº ¿¹·Î µÇ°í ÀÖ´Ù.
Birzer ´Â ÀÌ liberal conservatism À» ÇϳªÀÇ ¼±°ßÁö¸íÀÇ °¡Ä¡¸¦  °¡Áø °ÍÀÇ ¿¹·Î º¸°í ÀÖ´Ù.
Samuel Goldman Àº 1936³â¿¡ F. Scott Fitzgerald °¡ Á¦½ÃÇÑ ¸íÁ¦·Î º¸¼öÁÖÀǸ¦ ¸íÈ®È÷ ÇÏ·Á ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù. Fitzgerald ´Â ìé×µÀÇ Áö½ÄÀÎÀ» °ËÁõÇÏ´Â °ÍÀº ±×ÀÇ ¸¶À½¼Ó¿¡ µ¿½Ã¿¡ ´ë¸³µÇ´Â »ý°¢À» °¡Áú ¼ö ÀÖ´Â ´É·ÂÀ̶ó°í Çϸ鼭, ¿¹¸¦ µé¾î, Àý¸ÁÀ» Çϸ鼭µµ ±×°ÍÀ» Èñ¸ÁÀûÀ¸·Î µÇµµ·Ï °áÁ¤À» ³»¸®´Â °Í, ¶Ç ±×·¸°Ô µÇµµ·Ï ±â´ÉÇÒ ¼ö ÀÖ´Â ´É·ÂÀ» º¸À¯ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀ¸·Î °ËÁõÇÒ °ÍÀ» Á¦ÀÇÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.( Is a Conservative Crack-up on Horizon? May 4, 2017 )
GoldmanÀº Fitzgerald °¡ ÀڱⰡ Á¦½ÃÇÑ ¸íÁ¦¿¡ ´ëÇØ ºÎÁ¤ÀûÀ¸·Î »ý°¢Çϸ鼭, ÀÏ·ù Áö½ÄÀεµ ÀÌ·± Paradox ¿¡ ´ëÇØ ÀÌÇØÀÇ Á¦ÇÑÀûÀÎ ´É·Â ¹Û¿¡ ¾ø´Ù°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù. ¾î¶² ¸é¿¡¼­ Áö½Ä°ú ÀÇÁö´Â ±ÕÇüÀâ±â°¡ ºÒ°¡´ÉÇÏ´Ù°í ÇÏ°í, º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ°¡ ¹Ì·¡¿¡ ´ëÇØ ÀÏ°üµÈ ³í¸®¸¦ °¡ÁöÁö ¸øÇÏ´Â ÀÌÀ¯´Â º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ ³»ºÎ¿¡ ÀÖ´Â ÇÑ°èÀûÀÎ ±Ùº»ÀûÀÎ °æÇâÀ» ¹Ý¿µÇÑ °ÍÀ̶ó°í Çϸ鼭, ±×´Â ÀÌ°ÍÀº ÀÚÀ¯ÁÖÀÇ¿Í ÀüÅëÁÖÀÇ °£ÀÇ ³¸ÀÍÀº ±¸ºÐÀ¸·Î Ãà¼ÒµÉ ¼ö ¾øÀ¸³ª, ´Ü¼øÈ­ ½ÃÄÑ º¸ÀÚ¸é, ÀÌ°ÍÀº ÀÚÀ¯ÁÖÀÇ¿Í º¹°í ( Reaction ) ÁÖÀǶó°í ºÎ¸¦ ¼ö ÀÖ´Ù  
Mark Lilla ´Â Reaction ( ÜÖͯ, ¶Ç´Â ÚãÔÑ À¸·Î Çؼ® ) À» ÇöÀçÀÇ ÅðÆóÀû ȯ°æÀ» ¹Ù²Ù°í, ÀÌ»óÈ­µÈ °ú°Å¸¦ ȸº¹ÇÏ·Á´Â ÔÓÌÕÀ¸·Î Ç¥ÇöÇϸ鼭, »çȸÀû º¯È­¸¦ Ãß±¸Çϱâ À§Çؼ­´Â º¹°í ( ¹Ýµ¿ ) ¸¦ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀû °æÇâ°ú ±¸ºÐÇÏ¿©¾ß Çϸç, ½ÇÁ¦·Î Á¸ÀçÇÏ´Â °ÍÀ» ¼ÒÁßÈ÷ ÇØ¾ß ÈûÀ» ÁöÀûÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.
Áö³­ 4¿ù 15ÀÏ¿¡ ÀÖ¾ú´ø 21´ë ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Å¿¡¼­ Áý±Ç´çÀÎ ¹®ÀçÀÎÀÇ ¹ÎÁÖ´çÀº ºñ·Ê´ëÇ¥¸¦ Æ÷ÇÔÇÑ ÃÑ 300 ¼®ÀÇ ÀǼ® Áß¿¡¼­ ÃÖÁ¾ÀûÀ¸·Î 177¼®À» È®º¸ÇÔÀ¸·Î½á º¸¼ö¾ß´çÀÎ Çѱ¹´çÀ» Á¦¾ÐÇßÀ» »Ó ¾Æ´Ï¶ó °ú¹ÝÀ» 27¼®À» ³Ñ´Â ´ë½ÂÀ» °ÅµÎ¾ú´Ù.
Çѱ¹´çÀÇ ÂüÆÐÀÇ ¿øÀÎÀ» ±¸ÅÂ¾î ¾ð±ÞÇϱ⠺¸´Ù´Â ¹Ú±ÙÇý ´ëÅë·ÉÀÇ ÅºÇÙ ÀÌÈÄ °è¼ÓµÈ Çѱ¹´çÀÇ ±¸½ÉÁ¡À» ÀÒÀº È¥µ·°ú Àι°³­, ¼±°Å¸¦ ÀüÈÄÇؼ­ Çѱ¹´çÀÌ º¸ÀÎ °³º°Àû ½Ç¼ö, À±¸®Àû °áÁ¡ µîÀÌ ÀÌ °á°ú¸¦, °á°úÀûÀ¸·Î ¹ÎÁÖ´çÀÇ ´ë½ÂÀ» Çå³³ÇÑ °ÍÀ¸·Î º¸ÀδÙ.
¹Ú±ÙÇý Á¤±ÇÀÇ Áý±Ç½Ã ºÎÅÍ º¸¼ö´çÀ¸·Î¼­ÀÇ Çѱ¹´ç( »õ´©¸® ) Á¤±ÇÀÌ º¸ÀÎ ÇൿÀº º¸¼ö´çÀ¸·Î¼­ÀÇ ïáô÷àõÀ» ¾î¶² °ÍÀ¸·Î ÀÌÇØÇÏ°í ÀÖ¾ú´À³Ä ÇÏ´Â µ¥¼­ Ãâ¹ßÇÏ¿©, ´ëÅë·É ¼±°Å¿¡¼­µµ ´ç³»ÀÇ ºÐ¿­, ±× ´ëÅë·É È帷Π³ª¿Â »ç¶÷Àº ¶Ñ·ÇÇÑ Á¤Ã¥Àû ÀÇÁö³ª ½Å¼±ÇÑ Á¤Ã¥ ³»¿ëÀ» Á¦½ÃÇÏÁö ¸øÇßÀ» »Ó ¾Æ´Ï¶ó °í½ÄÀûÀÎ ¾ß´ç ´ëÇ¥°¡ º¸¿´´ø ´Ü½Ä ÅõÀï, »è¹ß µîÀ¸·Î ±¸ÅÂÀÇ¿¬ÇÑ ¸ð½ÀÀ» ¿¬ÃâÇßÀ» »ÓÀÌ´Ù.
´õ±¸³ª ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Å¸¦ ¾ÕµÎ°í ¿µÀÔÇÑ Àü ±º»çÁ¤±Ç ³ëÅÂ¿ì ´ëÅë·É ÀÇ ºñ¼­¸¦ Çß´ø »ç¶÷ÀÇ  ¿ªÇÒÀº ¾Ö¸Å ¸ðÈ£ÇÑ °ÍÀ̾ú´Ù. ¹®ÀçÀÎ ´ëÅë·É Èĺ¸ÀÇ Âü¸ð·Îµµ µîÀåÇß´ø  ±×´Â Áøº¸´çÀÇ Á¤Ã¥À¸·Î °æÁ¦ ¹ÎÁÖÁÖÀǶó´Â ¿ë¾î¸¦ Á¦½ÃÇß¾ú°í, ÀÌÁ¦ 21´ë ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Å¸¦ ¾ÕµÎ°í º¸¼ö´çÀÎ Çѱ¹´çÀÇ ¼±°Å Âü¸ð·Î ¶Ç µîÀåÇϸ鼭 ±× ÀÚ½ÅÀº ¹°·Ð À¯±ÇÀÚµéÀ» È¥¶õÀ¸·Î ¸ô¾Æ °¬´Ù.  
¼±°Å¸¦ ÁöÈÖÇϸ鼭, ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Åµî¿¡¼­ °è¼Ó ÂüÆи¦ Çß´ø ±×°¡ º¸¼ö´çÀÇ Àç°ÇÀ» À§ÇÑ Àι°·Î °Å·ÐµÇ°í ÀÖ´Ù´Â °ÍÀº Çѱ¹ Á¤Ä¡ÀÇ ¾ÆÀ̷δ϶ó°í ¹Û¿¡ ÇÒ ¼ö ¾ø´Ù.
30¿©³â °£ °è¼ÓµÈ ±º»ç Á¤±ÇÀÇ ±Ç·Â ¼Ó¿¡¼­ ±â¿ëÀÌ µÇ¾ú´ø ¹Î°£ Á¤Ä¡ÀεéÀº ´ÜÁö ±ºÀεéÀÇ ±Ç·Â Àå¾Ç ¾Æ·¡ ÇàÁ¤Àû ºÎ¹®¿¡¼­ ÇàÁ¤Àû È¿À²¼ºÀÇ ±Ø´ëÈ­¿¡¼­ÀÇ ±â¿©¸¦ ÅëÇØ, ÇàÁ¤ÀÎ À¸·Î¼­ÀÇ ÀÚ±â ÇÕ¸®È­¸¦ Ãß±¸ÇÏ´Â °ü·áÀû ¿ªÇÒ¿¡ Àͼ÷µÇ¾î ÀÖ¾ú´Ù.

Á¤ºÎÀÇ ±Ç·ÂÀº ±Ã±ØÀûÀ¸·Î ±¹¹ÎÀ¸·Î ºÎÅÍ ³ª¿À°í, ±× ±Ç·ÂÀº ±¹¹ÎÀÇ °¡Ä¡¸¦ ½ÇÇö½ÃÅ°´Â °ÍÀÌ ±× º»¿¬ÀÇ ÀÓ¹«¶ó´Â °ÍÀ» À̵éÀº ÀǵµÀûÀ¸·Î ¿Ü¸éÇÏ°í ÀÖ¾ú´Ù.´ÙÇàÀÎ °ÍÀº 21´ë ¼±°Å¸¦ ÅëÇØ º¸¼öÁø¿µ¿¡¼­ º¹°íÀûÀÌ°í ¹Ýµ¿ÀûÀÎ Á¤´çµéÀÌ ÅðÁøÇÏ°Ô µÇ¾ú´Ù´Â °ÍÀÌ´Ù.

º¸¼öÀÇ ÀÇ¹Ì¿Í Á¤Ã¥Àû Ư¼º
¹Ì±¹ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ ÀÇ ¿ø·ÎÀÎ Russell Kirk ´Â Conservatism À̶ó´Â ¸í»ç¸¦ ¾²±â º¸´Ù´Â Conservative ¶ó´Â Çü¿ë»ç·Î ¾µ °ÍÀ» ÁÖÀåÇß°í, ÀÌ°ÍÀ» ÁÂ, ¿ìÀÇ À̳äÀ¸·Î Á¦½ÃÇϱ⠺¸´Ù´Â ¸¶À½ÀÇ »óÅÂ, ½Ã¹Î »çȸ Áú¼­¸¦ ¹Ù¶óº¸´Â ¹æ¹ýÀ¸·Î º¸±â¸¦ ¿øÇß´Ù. ( The Conservative Mind ) Nisbet µµ ¹Ì±¹¿¡¼­ ÁÂ, ¿ì¶ó´Â ¿ë¾î¸¦ »ç¿ëÇÏ´Â µ¥´Â ¹Ý´ëÇÏÁö¸¸ , Conservatism À» À̳äÀÇ Çϳª·Î ÆľÇÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.
»ç½Ç»ó ¹Ì±¹¿¡¼­´Â Áøº¸, º¸¼ö Á¤´çÀ̶ó´Â Ç¥ÇöÀÌ ´õ ¸¹ÀÌ ¾²ÀÌ°í ÁÂ, ¿ì ¶ó´Â Ç¥ÇöÀº Àß ¾²ÀÌÁö ¾Ê°í ÀÖ´Ù. Peter Berkowitz ´Â 2008³â¿¡ ¾´ ±Û¿¡¼­ The European Left and Ours ¶ó°í ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ ÁÂÆĸ¦ ÁöĪÇϸ鼭 À¯·´ ÁÂÆÄ¿Í ºñ±³¸¦ ÇÏ°í Àִµ¥, ÁÖ·Î Sanders ¿Í °°Àº À¯·´ÁÂÆĸ¦ ÅëÇØ »çȸÁÖÀǸ¦ ºñ±³ÇÏ·Á´Â ÀÔÀå¿¡¼­ ¾ð±ÞÇϸ鼭 ¿¹¸¦ µé¾î ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ »çȸÁÖÀÇ´Â À¯·´ÀÇ Ãʱ⠻çȸÁÖÀÇ ´Ü°è¶ó°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖÀ¸³ª, ÀÌ°ÍÀº ÀÇ·áÁ¦µµ¸¦ ÀǽÄÇÑ °ÍÀ¸·Î º¸À̸ç, ¿ª»çÀû À¯·´ »çȸÁÖÀÇÀÇ ¹ßÀü °úÁ¤À» Á¦´ë·Î ÀÌÇØÇÏÁö ¸øÇÑ °ÍÀ¸·Î º¸ÀδÙ.
Nisbet °¡ ÁÖÀåÇÏ´Â °Íó·³ À¯·´ÀÇ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀÇ ½Ã¹ßÀ» Burke ¿¡¼­ ã°í, ¶Ç »çȸÁÖÀÇÀÇ ½Ã¹ßÀ» Marx ¿¡¼­ ã´Â ´Ù¸é, ÇÁ¶û½º¿¡¼­ °æÁ¦Àû º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀÇ ¿ø·Î ( Economie Politique )·Î ÀÏÄþî Áö´Â Antoine de Montchrestien ( 1575-1621 ) ÀÇ Á¸Àç´Â Àǹ̰¡ ¾ø°Ô µÈ´Ù.
À¯·´¿¡¼­ ±ºÁÖ¸¦ Áß½ÉÀ¸·Î ÁÂÃø¿¡ ½ÅÈï »ó°ø°èÃþ, ¿ìÃø¿¡ ÅäÁö ÁöÁÖ ¹× ±ÍÁ· °èÃþÀ» µÐ »ïºÎȸÀÇÀÇ ±¸¼º¿¡¼­ ½ÃÀÛµÈ ÁÂ, ¿ìÀÇ °³³äÀº ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ Áøº¸¿Í º¸¼öÀÇ °³³ä°ú´Â ±× »çȸÀû Àǹ̰¡ ´Ù¸£´Ù.
Stephen Tonsors´Â º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ°¡ ÀüÅëÀ» Áß½ÃÇÏÁö¸¸ ±× ÀüÅëÀÇ ¶óƾ¾î ¾î¿øÀ» ÅëÇØ ±× ÀüÅë ( tradere )À̶õ °ÍÀº ±× Àǹ̰¡ ¼º½º·¯¿î °Í, ¼± ÇÑ °Í, ÁÁÀº °Í µîÀ» º¸°üÇÏ´Â Àå¼Ò·Î ¾²¿´´ø °ÍÀ» ÁöÀûÇϸ鼭,Áß¼¼ÀÇ ±³È¸, ´ëÇÐ µîÀÌ Áß½ÉÀÌ µÈ ºñ Á¤Ä¡Àû ºÐ¾ß °ð, ¿¹¼ú, ¹®ÇÐ, »î¿¡¼­ Áß¿ä½Ã µÇ´ø °ÍÀÓÀ» °­Á¶ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.( Equality, Decadence and Modernity, ISI Books, Washington 2005)
¹Ì±¹¿¡¼­ Kirk °¡ º¸¼öÁÖÀǸ¦ ¾ð±ÞÇϸ鼭, º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ´Â ÀüÅë ¸¸À¸·Î »çȸ¸¦ À̲ø±â¿¡ ÃæºÐÇÑ °ÍÀº ¾Æ´Ï¸ç, ÀÌ°ÍÀ» Á¦´ë·Î ÀÌÇØÇϱâ À§Çؼ­´Â ¿©·¯ ¼¼´ë¸¦ ÅëÇØ ³»·Á¿À´Â ¾ç½É°ú Áö¼ºÀ» ´õ ¹ßÀü½ÃÅ°´Â °ÇÀüÇÑ º¯È­°¡ ÇÊ¿äÇÏ´Ù°í Çϸ鼭, »ç¶÷µéÀÇ °æÇèÀÇ ¿ª»çÀû ¿¬¼Ó¼º°ú Áö¼ÓÀûÀÎ µµ´öÀû Áú¼­°¡ ÇÊ¿äÇϸç, µµ´öÀû Áø½ÇÀº ¿µ±¸ÇÑ °ÍÀ̶ó°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù
»ç¶÷µéÀÌ Áß³â±â¿¡ µé¾î ¼­¸é¼­ Æø·ÂÀû °ø»êÁÖÀǸ¦ ¹þ¾î³ª·Á´Â ¸ð½ÀÀ» º¸ÀÌ´Â °ÍÀº °³ÀÎÀû ÀνÄÀÇ º¯È­¿¡¸¸ ±×Ä¡´Â °ÍÀÌ ¾Æ´Ï¶ó, ±¹°¡³ª Á¤´çÀÇ °æ¿ìµµ ¸¶Âù°¡Áö¶ó°í ÇÒ ¼ö ÀÖ´Ù.
1976³â ½ºÆäÀÎÀÇ °ø»ê´ç ÃÑÀç Santiago Carillo°¡ ¾´ "Eurocommunism et Etat" ¿¡¼­ »çȸÁÖÀÇ·Î À̸£´Â ±æÀº ¹Ýµå½Ã Soviet ÀûÀÎ °Í¸¸Àº ¾Æ´Ï´Ù¶ó´Â ÁÖÀåÀ» Çϸ鼭, ¼­À¯·´ ±¹°¡µéÀÇ µ¶ÀÚÀû ÀÌ·ÐÀ» Á¦½ÃÇÑ °ÍÀº Soviet Communism ÀÇ ºØ±«ÀÇ ½ÃÀÛÀ» ¾Ë¸®´Â ½ÅÈ£¿´´Ù°í ÇÒ ¼ö ÀÖ´Ù.
Raymond Aron ÀÌ °ø»êÁÖÀÇ Æø·ÂÇõ¸íÀ» À§ÇÑ °è±Þ °³³äÀÌ ÇÊ¿äÇÑ °ÍÀ¸·Î °ø»êÁÖÀÇÀÚµéÀº °­Á¶ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù°í ÁÖÀåÇϸ鼭, ±×·¯³ª ±×´Â ÇÁ¶û½º¿¡´Â °è±Þ °³³äÀÌ ¾ø°í °èÃþ ( Couche ) ¸¸ ÀÖÀ» »ÓÀ̶ó°í ÇÑ °ÍÀº À§¿Í °°Àº ÃëÁö¸¦ °¡Áö´Â °ÍÀÌ´Ù. Berkowitz °¡ ÁöÀûÇÑ °Íó·³, Levy ³ª Sarkozy °¡ À¯·´ ÁÂÆĵéÀÇ ³ë¼â¼ºÀ» ³ë¸®°í ±× ÈÄ Sarkozy °¡ Áý±ÇÇÏ°Ô µÈ °ÍÀº ¿ì¿¬ÇÑ °ÍÀÌ ¾Æ´Ï´Ù.
1976³â ÀÌÈÄ À¯·´ ÁÂÆĵéÀº ±× ³ë¼â¼ºÀ¸·Î ÀÎÇØ »ó½ÇÇÑ ±¹¹ÎµéÀÇ ½Å·Ú°¨À» ȸº¹Çϱâ À§ÇØ ¿©·¯ º¯È­¸¦ ²Ï ÇØ¾ß Çß´Ù. ±×µéÀº »õ·Î¿î  Image·Î À¯±ÇÀÚµéÀ» »ç·Î Àâ¾Æ¾ß Çß´Ù. 2007³â ÀÖ¾ú´ø Sarkozy ( éÓ )¿Í Royal ( ñ§)ÀÇ TV ´ë¼± Åä·ÐÀº Ä¡¿­Çß°í Royal ÀÌ Sarkozy ¸¦ K.O. ½ÃÄ×´Ù°í ¾ð·ÐÀÌ ¶°µé¾úÁö¸¸, Sarkozy ´Â ¹«³­ÇÑ ½Â¸®¸¦ °ÅµÎ¾ú´Ù. ÇÁ¶û½º¿¡¼­´Â Áßµµ ¿ìÆÄ°¡ °è¼Ó Áý±ÇÇÏ°í ÀÖ¾ú°í, ´Ù¸¥ ³ª¶óµé¿¡¼­´Â Áßµµ ÁÂÆÄ°¡ ½Â¸®¸¦ °ÅµÎ´Â ¸ð½Àµµ ÀÖ¾ú´Ù.
°á±¹ ±¹¹ÎÀÇ 6-70 % ¿¡ ´ÞÇÏ´Â Áß»êÃþÀ» ¾î¶»°Ô È¿°úÀûÀ¸·Î °ø·«ÇÏ´À³Ä°¡ ±× ½Â¸®ÀÇ °ü°ÇÀ̶ó´Â °ÍÀº ÀÚ¸íÇÏ´Ù.ÀÌÁ¦ ±ØÁ³ª ±Ø¿ì°¡ µæ¼¼ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀ» º¸±â´Â ´õ Èûµé¾î Á³´Ù.

Çѱ¹ º¸¼öÁ¤´çÀÇ ¼±ÅÃ
»ç½Ç»ó ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ º¸¼ö´çµµ ºÐ¿­ÀÇ »óÅ¿¡ ÀÖ´Ù°í º¸¾Æµµ ¹«¹æÇÒ °Í °°´Ù. ¹Ì±¹ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇÀÇ ¿ø·Î°ÝÀÎ Kirk ´Â Bush ´ëÅë·É°úÀÇ ´ë¿Ü ±º»çÀû °³ÀÔ ¹®Á¦·Î ºÒÈ­¸¦ °Þ¾ú°í 1994³â¿¡ Ÿ°è¸¦ Çß´Ù. ÀÌ ±ÛÀÇ ¼­µÎ¿¡ ¾ð±ÞÇÑ Cohen µµ Trump ´ëÅë·É°úÀÇ ºÒÈ­·Î °øÈ­´çÀ» Å»Å𸦠Çß´Ù.
Gleaves Whitney ´Â ¹Ì±¹ÀÇ º¸¼öÁÖÀÇ°¡ Regress, Fractious ¿¡ ÀÖ´Ù°í Æò°¡Çϸ鼭, ¹Ì±¹¿¡¼­ÀÇ ±âµ¶±³Àû, °è¸ùÀû, ³¶¸¸Àû Ư¼ºÀÇ ±Ù´ë¼ºÀÇ Å¾çÀÌ ±× ºûÀ» ÀÒ°í Èı⠱ٴëÁÖÀÇÀÇ ´ÞÀÌ ¶ßÀÚ ¹Ì±¹ÀεéÀÇ ½Å³ä, ½Å¾ÓÀûÀÌ°í Á¤½ÅÀûÀÎ ÈûÀ» È帮°Ô ÇÏ´Â ¾îµÎ¿òÀÇ ½Ã±â·Î µé¾î¼­°Ô ÇÏ¿´´Ù°í ÁöÀûÇß´Ù. ±×´Â ÀÌ°ÍÀ» ´Ù½Ã ½Å³äÀ» ȸº¹ÇÏ°Ô Çϱâ À§Çؼ­´Â °øµ¿ÀÇ ±â¹Ý°ú °ü·ÃµÈ º¸¼öÀû ½Å³äÀ» ´Ù½Ã °è¹ßÇÏ°í, ´õ¿í À¶ÇÕÀ» ÀÌ·ç¸é¼­ »ý»êÀû ±äÀåÀ» ÅëÇÑ º¸¼öÀû °¡Ä¡ÀÇ ½ÇÇöÀ» Ã˱¸Çß´Ù.( How can we form a more perfect union in our fractious Age? 2020, 04, 14).
21´ë ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Å¿¡¼­ÀÇ °á°ú¸¦ º¼ ÇÊ¿ä°¡ ÀÖ´Ù. ÀÌ°ÍÀº ±× ÆйèÀÇ ¼º°Ý°ú ¿øÀÎÀ» ¹àÈ÷´Âµ¥µµ µµ¿òÀ» ÁÙ ¼ö°¡ ÀÖ´Ù. Çѱ¹´çÀº ºñ·Ê´ëÇ¥¸¦ Æ÷ÇÔÇÏ¿©, 84¼®ÀÇ ÀǼ®À» ȹµæÇß´Ù .ÀÌ°ÍÀº º¸¼ö´çÀÌ Á¤±ÇÀ» Àå¾ÇÇÏ¿´À¸³ª, 20´ë ±¹È¸ÀÇ¿ø ¼±°Å ( 2016 )¿¡¼­ ÀÌ¹Ì ¹ÎÁÖ´ç¿¡ µÚÃÄ젔À½¿¡µµ, ±×·¡µµ 122¼®À» È®º¸Çß´ø °Í¿¡¼­ º¸¾Æµµ ÂüÆп´°í, ºñ·Ê´ëÇ¥ 19¼®À» Á¦¿ÜÇÏ°í Áö¿ª±¸¸¦ º¸¸é, ´ë±¸ 11¼®, °æºÏ 13¼®, °æ³² 12¼® À¸·Î Çѱ¹´çÀÌ È¹µæÇÑ ÀǼ® ¼öÀÇ Àý¹Ý ÀÌ»óÀ» ¿µ³² Áö¿ª¿¡¼­ ȹµæÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù. Çѱ¹´çÀº È£³² Áö¿ª¿¡¼­ ÀǼ®À» È®º¸ÇÏÁö ¸øÇß°í, ¹Ý¸é ¹ÎÁÖ´çÀº ´ë±¸Áö¿ª¿¡¼­ ÀǼ®À» ¾òÁö ¸øÇßÀ» »Ó °æ³², ºÎ»ê, µîÁö¿¡¼­ ÀǼ®À» È®º¸ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù. Çѱ¹´çÀÇ ¼­¿ï, °æ±â ÀÎõ µî, Àα¸ÀÇ ¹Ý ÀÌ»óÀÌ ÀÖ´Â ¼öµµ±Ç¿¡¼­ÀÇ µæÇ¥ °á°ú´Â Ä¡¸íÀûÀ̾ú´Ù.
Çѱ¹´çÀÇ ¿ø³» ´ëÇ¥ ¼±Ãâ¿¡¼­ ´ë±¸ ¼­¿ï¿¡¼­¸¸ Èĺ¸ÀÚ¸¦ ³Â°í, °á°úÀûÀ¸·Î °¡Àå ¸¹Àº ÀǼ®À» ¹èÃâÇØ ³½ ´ë±¸¿¡¼­ ¿ø³» ´ëÇ¥°¡ ³ª¿Ô´Ù. ¼±ÃâµÈ ¿ø³» ´ëÇ¥´Â ¼±°Å¸¦ Ã¥ÀÓÁ³´ø Àλ縦 ´Ù½Ã ±â¿ëÇÒ Àǻ縦 º¸¿´Áö¸¸ ÀÌ°ÍÀº ³Ê¹« ¿Ï¸¸ÇÏ°í À§±â ÀǽÄÀÌ °á¿©µÈ »ý°¢ÀÌ´Ù. Á» ´õ ¸¹Àº Àλçµé°ú °ßÇظ¦ ±³È¯ÇÏ°í, º¸¼ö Á¤´çÀÇ ïáô÷àõÀ» È®¸³Çϱâ À§ÇÑ Æø³Ð°í, Àå±âÀûÀÎ Æ÷¼®À» Æì·Á´Â ¼ö¿ëÀûÀÎ ÀÚ¼¼°¡ ÇÊ¿äÇÏ´Ù.
ÇöÀç º¸¼öÁ¤´ç¿¡°Ô °¡Àå Áß¿äÇÏ°í ÇÊ¿äÇÑ °ÍÀº Precursor ¸¦ ±¸ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀÌ´Ù. ´Ü¼øÇÑ ÁöµµÀÚ°¡ ÇÊ¿äÇÑ °ÍÀÌ ¾Æ´Ï¶ó  ÀÌ À§±â¸¦ ±Øº¹ÇÏ°í º¸¼öÀÇ °¡Ä¡, ¸ñÇ¥¸¦ ¼³Á¤ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀº ¹°·Ð ´ç¿øµé¿¡ ´ëÇÑ À±¸®Àû ±â°­°ú ´ç Á¤Ã¥ÀÇ °­·ÂÇÑ µ¿Á¶¸¦ °¡Á® ¿Ã ¼ö ÀÖ´Â °³ÇõÀû ¼±µµ¸¦ À̲ø¾î ³»¾î ±¹¹ÎÀÇ ½Å·Ú¸¦ ȹµæÇÒ ¼ö ÀÖ´Â ´É·ÂÀÇ ¼ÒÀ¯ÀÚ°¡ ÇÊ¿äÇÑ °ÍÀÌ´Ù.
¿©±â¼­ Áß¿äÇÑ °ÍÀº Áøº¸ ¿©´çÀ» ±Øº¹Çϱâ À§ÇÑ À̳äÀû ÆľÇÀÌ ÀÌ·ç¾î Áö°í ÀÌ À§¿¡ º¸¼öÀÇ °¡Ä¡¸¦ ±Ø´ëÈ­ÇÑ Á¤Ã¥ ³Ø¼­½º¸¦ Çü¼ºÇÒ Á¤Ã¥ Áý´ÜÀ» ±¸ºñÇÏ´Â °ÍÀÌ´Ù.
À§¿¡¼­µµ ¾ð±ÞÇßÁö¸¸ º¸¼ö´çÀº 6-70%¿¡ ´ÞÇÏ´Â Áß»êÃþÀ» ´ë»óÀ¸·Î ÇÑ ¸¸Å­ À̵éÀÇ ½Å·Ú¸¦ ´Ù½Ã ȸº¹ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀÌ ½Â¸®ÀÇ °ü°ÇÀÌ´Ù. ¿©±â¿¡ ¿Õµµ³ª Æijª¼¼¾Æ´Â ¾ø´Ù. ±¹¹ÎÀÇ °ü½ÉÀÇ ¸ÆÀ» ³õÁöÁö ¾Ê°í, ±× º¯È­ÀÇ Ãß¼¼¸¦  ²öÁú±â°Ô ÃßÀûÇϸ鼭 °³ÀÔÀ» ÇÏ´Â °ÍÀÌ´Ù. ÀÌ°ÍÀÌ ¸¶Å©·ÕÀÌ ½Çõ¿¡ ¿Å±ä ¹æ¹ýÀÌ´Ù.
¼±°Å ±â°£ ÀüÈÄÇÏ¿© Áöµµ±Þ Àλ縦 4-5¸íÀ» ±³Ã¼Çϸ鼭 º¯È­¸¦ ½ÃµµÇÏ¿´Áö¸¸ °á±¹ ½Ã°£¸¸ Çã¼ÛÇÑ °á°ú·Î ³ªÅ¸³µ°í, ÀÌ°ÍÀÌ ÁÁµç ½Èµç ´çÀÇ ïÎôòàõ, ¸Å³Ê¸®Áò¿¡ ºüÁø ´ç ±â±¸ÀÇ ¾ÈÀÌÇÑ ¿î¿µÀ» °¡Á®¿Ô°í °á±¹Àº ÇØ´çÀû Çö»óÀ¸·Î È帣µµ·Ï Çß´Ù°í º¸ÀδÙ.
ÀÌÁ¦ º¸¼ö´çÀÇ Precursor ¸¦ È®º¸ÇÏ´Â ¹®Á¦´Â Á¤´ç¸¸ÀÇ  ºÎÈ°À» À§ÇÑ °ÍÀÌ ¾Æ´Ï¶ó ±¸±¹ÀÇ Â÷¿ø¿¡¼­ º¸¼öÀÇ ±Ù°£À» Àç°ÇÇÏ°í ³ª¶óÀÇ ±â°­À» ´Ù½Ã ¹Ù·Î Àâ´Â Â÷¿ø¿¡¼­ ½Çõ¿¡ ¿Å°Ü¾ß ÇÒ °úÁ¦ÀÓÀ» ÀνÄÇØ¾ß Ç× °ÍÀÌ´Ù.
¸¶Áö¸·À¸·Î Tonsor °¡ ±×ÀÇ Ã¥ ¼­¹®¿¡¼­ ¾´ ¸»À» ¼Ò°³ÇÏ°íÀÚ ÇÑ´Ù. ±×´Â ¡°¹®È­¿Í ¹®¸íÀº ÇÕ¸®Àû ¸ñÀûÀ» °¡Áö°í ÇàÇÏ´Â »ç¶÷µé¿¡°Ô¼­ º¸´Ù´Â, Æò¹üÇÑ Àΰ£µéÀÇ ÇÊ¿ä¿Í ÀηùÀÇ Ãß±¸¸¦ ÃÑÇÕÇÑ °Í¿¡¼­ ±× ÀÚ¸®¸¦ Â÷ÁöÇÒ ¼ö ÀÖ´Ù°í Çϸ鼭, À̵éÀÌ Ãß±¸ÇÏ´Â Áú¼­, ¾Èº¸, »ç¶û, ¾Æ¸§´Ù¿ò,°ú Áø½ÇÀ» ÅëÇؼ­ °¡´ÉÇÏ´Ù°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù. »çȸ´Â °³ÀÎÀû ¿å±¸º¸´Ù´Â Æò¹üÇÑ »ç¶÷µéÀÇ ÇÊ¿ä¿¡ ÀÇÇØ À¯ÁöµÈ´Ù.¡±°í ÇÏ°í ÀÖ´Ù.


growsonyou 24-05-22 18:46
´äº¯ »èÁ¦  
https://influence.co/mudeleo
https://www.designspiration.com/camisetaliga/
https://hub.docker.com/u/mudeleo
https://www.xaphyr.com/mudeleo
https://www.buzzbii.com/mudeleo
https://gifyu.com/mudeleo
https://www.onfeetnation.com/profile/Carloslin
https://www.free-ebooks.net/profile/1409404/mude-leo
https://www.metooo.io/u/mudeleo
https://os.mbed.com/users/mudeleo/
https://pastebin.com/u/mudeleo
https://reedsy.com/discovery/user/mudeleo
https://www.brownbook.net/business/52512602/maillotkane/
https://mastodon.top/@mudeleo
https://leasedadspace.com/members/mudeleo/
https://kuula.co/profile/mudeleo/
https://javabyab.com/user/camisetaliga
https://www.easypano.com/forum/profile/29359.html
https://assises.cc-seignanx.fr/profiles/maillot2022/activity
https://borgerkraft.no/profiles/maillot2022/activity
https://www.rolepages.com/characters/maillot2022/profile/
https://myearthcam.com/maillot2022
https://getinkspired.com/en/u/maillot2022/
https://pyweek.org/u/maillotdefoot/
https://www.hamqth.com/maillot2022
https://huduma.social/camisetaliga
https://zumvu.com/maillot2022/
https://gettogether.community/profile/30681/
http://www.genina.com/user/profile/2141965.page
https://replit.com/@jadonsen
https://www.dermandar.com/user/maillotdefoot/
https://sleek.bio/jadonsen
https://confengine.com/user/jadonsen
https://www.mintme.com/profile/maillotdefoot
https://mastodon.cloud/@maillotdefoot
https://velopiter.spb.ru/profile/82764-maillotdefoot/?tab=field_core_pfield_1
https://www.renderosity.com/users/maillotdefoot
https://www.mathisfunforum.com/profile.php?id=240510
https://www.blackhatworld.com/members/maillotdefoot.1593163/about
https://cs.astronomy.com/members/maillotdefoot/default.aspx
https://www.salesforce.com/trailblazer/jadonsen
https://projectnursery.com/author/maillotdefoot/
https://lichess.org/@/maillotdefoot
http://freestyler.ws/user/377819/Jadonsen
https://meadd.com/jadonsen/
https://www.careercup.com/user?id=6245284571512832
https://www.starnow.com/u/camisetaliga/
https://doodleordie.com/profile/maillotdefoot
https://www.accountingweb.co.uk/profile/camisetaliga
https://uniquethis.com/profile/camisetaliga
http://codepad.org/users/camisetaliga
https://forum.earlybird.club/members/maillotdefoot.2150860/about
http://douga.fudousan.info/profile.php?u=futbol2020
https://www.pintradingdb.com/forum/member.php?action=profile&uid=67693
https://community.hodinkee.com/members/rafemim
http://tupalo.com/fr/users/3442435
https://list.ly/rafemim/
https://globalcatalog.com/rafemim.fr
http://www.remotecentral.com/cgi-bin/forums/members/viewprofile.cgi?33pspz
https://camp-fire.jp/profile/rafemim
https://www.jigsawplanet.com/rafemim
https://creator.wonderhowto.com/maillotdefoot/
https://talk.plesk.com/members/rafemim.255003/about
https://www.storeboard.com/rafemim
https://www.getlisteduae.com/listings/equipement-de-foot-pas-cher
https://forumreklamowe.com/User-rafemim
https://www.churchstaffing.com/church/184298/rafemim/
https://www.catchafire.org/profiles/2194456/
https://www.hackster.io/rafemim
https://community.atlassian.com/t5/user/v2/viewprofilepage/user-id/4990453
https://www.flickr.com/people/rafemim/
https://www.plurk.com/rafemim
https://gab.com/rafemim
https://band.us/band/85617708/intro
https://independent.academia.edu/camisetaligachen
https://nhattao.com/members/andylan.3764833/
https://roomstyler.com/users/andylan
https://vhearts.net/andylan
https://www.techinasia.com/profile/andy-lan
https://blend.io/andylan
https://kustomcoachwerks.com/Forums/users/andylan/
https://player.ru/member.php?u=414687
https://www.lifeofpix.com/p/andylan/
https://audiomack.com/andylan
http://programujte.com/profil/42419-andylan/
https://forum.dzpknews.com/space-uid-434512.html
https://play.eslgaming.com/player/18629051/
https://my.desktopnexus.com/andylan/
https://repo.getmonero.org/Amysen
https://www.bigsoccer.com/members/hugo2017.301608/
https://www.tabletennisdaily.com/forum/members/amysen.111451/about
https://www.credly.com/users/amysen/badges
https://triberr.com/Amysen
https://www.mapleprimes.com/users/Amysen
https://guides.co/a/amysen
https://www.intensedebate.com/people/amysen22
https://forum.acronis.com/user/428257
https://www.longisland.com/profile/amysen
https://8tracks.com/amysenx
https://hypothes.is/users/amysen
https://pxhere.com/en/photographer/3903296
https://www.exchangle.com/amysen
https://disqus.com/by/amysen/about/
https://www.diigo.com/profile/amysen
https://www.stageit.com/futbol2020
https://community.perchcms.com/user/4477-amysen/?editOnInit=true
https://www.plimbi.com/author/49451/Suarez2022
http://bioimagingcore.be/q2a/user/amysen
http://qa.rudnik.mobi/index.php?qa=user&qa_1=amysenem
https://fliphtml5.com/homepage/sdfwt
https://letterboxd.com/amysen/
https://www.chordie.com/forum/profile.php?id=1508058
https://amysen.livejournal.com/profile
https://www.myminifactory.com/users/Alamy
http://hawkee.com/profile/2506358
http://hawkee.com/snippet/24167/
https://www.metroflog.co/amysen
https://www.penname.me/@amysen
https://twitback.com/amysen
http://molbiol.ru/forums/index.php?showuser=1250228
http://atlas.dustforce.com/user/amysen
https://www.speedrun.com/user/amysen
https://fr.quora.com/profile/Alamy-3/
https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/158578949-alamy
https://www.skillshare.com/profile/Alamy-Ben/984631450
https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alamyben
https://www.hulkshare.com/frmaillots2017
https://www.pozible.com/profile/alamy
https://www.yourquote.in/alamy-ben-dntd9/quotes
https://www.veoh.com/users/maillotdefoot2022
https://www.bahamaslocal.com/userprofile/168212/Alamy123.html
https://skitterphoto.com/photographers/22825/alamy123
http://forum.dmec.vn/index.php?members/maillotdefoot.26090/
http://6giay.vn/members/alamy123.43108/
https://answerpail.com/index.php/user/Alamy123
https://www.babelcube.com/user/alamy-ben
https://www.pling.com/u/alamy123/
https://www.opendesktop.org/u/alamy123
https://www.opencode.net/alamy123
https://note.com/alamy123/
https://rentry.co/hriav
https://www.wibki.com/alamy123
http://www.video-bookmark.com/bookmark/5530064/equipement-de-foot
https://aipi.social/@alamy123
https://the-dots.com/users/alamy-ben-1344750
https://www.pexels.com/@alamy-ben-392990188/
https://gab.com/rafemim/posts/110173075975639132
https://my.omsystem.com/members/manuepinze
https://band.us/band/90813241/post/1
https://stylowi.pl/59101924
https://roosterteeth.com/g/post/993d0a06-bce5-4bd4-8741-3fa466bb965f
https://profile.hatena.ne.jp/alamy123/
https://www.divephotoguide.com/user/alamy123
https://app.zintro.com/profile/alamy123
http://www.rohitab.com/discuss/user/1266756-alamy123/
https://www.facer.io/u/alamy123
https://www.mifare.net/support/forum/users/alamy123/
https://buddypress.org/members/maillotsdefoot/profile/
https://www.drupalgovcon.org/user/440696
https://experiment.com/users/aalamy123
https://pushkino.tv/forum/user/101104/
https://www.australia-australie.com/membres/alamy123/profile/
https://440hz.my/forums/users/alamy123/
https://www.bitsdujour.com/profiles/vwYzgm
https://www.abavala.com/forums/membre/alamy123/
https://alexathemes.net/forums/users/ckgogo01/
http://dixxodrom.ru/forums/users/alamy123/
https://www.fimfiction.net/user/585454/alamy123
http://www.nfomedia.com/profile?uid=rLcYggG
https://nexusconsultancy.co.uk/forums/users/alamy123/
https://tavisraeli.co.il/forums/users/alamy123/
https://ivrpa.org/forums/users/maillotdefoot/
https://puremtgo.com/users/maillotdefoot
https://www.funddreamer.com/users/ise-chen
https://offcourse.co/users/profile/alamy123/
https://www.weblancer.net/users/alamy123/
https://bandori.party/user/176785/alamy123/
https://www.itinerantangler.com/blog/board/forums/users/alamy123/
https://www.pageorama.com/?p=boutiquemaillotdefoot
https://studiopress.community/users/maillotdefoot/
https://www.theyeshivaworld.com/coffeeroom/users/alamy123
https://www.dnxjobs.de/users/alamy123
https://www.windsurf.co.uk/forums/users/carloslin/
https://www.angrybirdsnest.com/members/alamy123/profile/
https://www.fantasyplanet.cz/diskuzni-fora/users/alamy123/
https://lu.ma/fxek3kpb
http://www.heromachine.com/forums/users/maillotdefoot/
https://www.360cities.net/profile/alamy123
https://www.noteflight.com/profile/3492c3a8c1f2b883f3545a9bf2b82f85676f7415
https://www.zotero.org/alamy123/cv
https://app.roll20.net/users/11985749/alamy123
https://pinshape.com/users/2635929-alamy123
https://able2know.org/user/maillotdefoot/
https://fileforum.com/profile/maillotdefoot
https://www.giantbomb.com/profile/alamy123/
https://www.gamespot.com/profile/maillotlyon/
http://vetstate.ru/forum/?PAGE_NAME=profile_view&UID=80158
https://lynk.id/maillotlyon
https://whitehat.vn/members/maillotlyon.99582/about
https://www.englishbaby.com/findfriends/gallery/detail/2443008
https://forum.turkerview.com/members/maillotlyon.102794/
https://writeablog.net/3l15fpt9cw
https://www.careeredlounge.com/pg/profile/maillotlyon
https://www.jqwidgets.com/community/users/maillotlyon/
https://www.engineering.com/profile/maillotlyon
http://giahoclaixe.net/members/maillotlyon.31857/
https://www.pinterest.fr/naomaillotpsg/
https://myspace.com/naomaillotpsg
https://www.behance.net/maillotpsg
https://soundcloud.com/naomaillotpsg
https://gravatar.com/camisetasdefutbol2015
https://legenden-von-andor.de/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=13949
https://miarroba.com/futbol2020
https://www.growsonyou.com/naomaillotpsg/profile
https://forums.hostsearch.com/member.php?225007-futbol2020
tealfeed 24-05-30 16:35
´äº¯ »èÁ¦  
https://mastodon.online/@maillotlyon
https://universeodon.com/@maillotlyon
https://mas.to/@maillotlyon
https://biiut.com/maillotlyon
https://mez.ink/maillotlyon
https://joy.link/maillotlyon
https://potofu.me/maillotlyon
https://www.vevioz.com/maillotkane
https://bulios.com/@maillotkane
https://www.walkscore.com/people/177001956224/maillotkane
https://www.nintendo-master.com/profil/maillotkane
https://us.enrollbusiness.com/BusinessProfile/6533883/maillotkane
https://www.namestation.com/user/camisetaliga2015
https://www.snipesocial.co.uk/maillotkane
https://digitalmarketingdeal.com/profile/maillotkane
https://decidim.santjaumedelsdomenys.cat/profiles/maillotkane/activity
https://todon.ploud.fr/@maillotkane
https://bimber.bringthepixel.com/community/buddypress/members/camisetaligachen/profile/
https://www.easyfie.com/maillotkane
https://magnitt.com/startups/maillotkane-78626
https://www.freelistingusa.com/listings/maillotkane
https://help.orrs.de/user/maillotkane
https://participer.ge.ch/profiles/maillotkane/activity?locale=en
https://www.decidimmataro.cat/profiles/maillotkane/activity
https://hangoutshelp.net/user/maillotkane
http://emseyi.com/user/maillotkane
https://subscribe.ru/author/31319419
https://www.webwiki.fr/frmaillots2022.com
https://app.talkshoe.com/user/maillotkane
https://newspicks.com/user/9862507
https://www.theexeterdaily.co.uk/users/maillotkane
https://www.bigbasstabs.com/profile/80452.html
https://schoolido.lu/user/maillotkane/
https://www.warriorforum.com/members/maillotkane.html
https://connectgalaxy.com/maillotkane
https://www.giveawayoftheday.com/forums/profile/165528
https://www.provenexpert.com/maillotkane/
https://doselect.com/@maillotkane
https://myopportunity.com/profile/maillot-kane/sl
https://defol.io/camisetaliga-che
https://booksloom.com/author/maillotkane/
https://www.anibookmark.com/user/maillotkane.html
https://www.iglinks.io/camisetaliga2015-3mo
https://hcgdietinfo.com/hcgdietforums/members/maillotkane/
https://www.fundable.com/maillot-kane
https://www.serialzone.cz/uzivatele/206671-maillotkane/
https://chart-studio.plotly.com/~maillotkane#/
https://www.fullhires.com/author/maillotkane/
https://devdojo.com/maillotkane
https://www.multichain.com/qa/user/maillotkane
https://rotorbuilds.com/profile/32879/
https://www.awwwards.com/maillotkane/
https://mecabricks.com/en/user/maillotkane
https://forum.liquidbounce.net/user/maillotkane
https://community.articulate.com/users/maillotkane
https://kktix.com/user/5179844
https://giveit.link/maillotkane
https://velog.io/@maillotlyon/Ilkay-Gndogan-le-maestro-du-milieu-de-terrain-de-Manchester-City-fait-en-Bundesliga
https://www.ilcirotano.it/annunci/author/maillotlyon/
https://www.are.na/block/24835319
https://exchange.prx.org/series/45961-malgre-le-manque-de-temps-de-jeu-le-joueur-de-23
https://steemit.com/juventus/@maillotlyon/nouveau-maillot-domicile-juventus-2023-2024-magasin
https://www.notebook.ai/documents/235269
https://start.me/p/KMeQnn/raphinha-tait-en-feu-il-est-lun-des-rares-joueu
https://wakelet.com/wake/nU6_wN3hlak-549vpFQkE
https://trakteer.id/maillotlyon/post/aston-villa-serait-interesse-par-lailier-de-villarreal-yeremi-pino-gtlfw
https://baskadia.com/post/ous8
https://www.nationalelfservice.net/author/maillotlyon/
https://zenwriting.net/ysqlcnb6am
https://educatorpages.com/site/maillotlyon/pages/jules-kounde-a-demande-a-quitter-barcelone-cet-ete
https://www.laonsw.net/web/rafemim/home
https://maillotlyon.splashthat.com/
https://footballnews.onlc.fr/
https://maillotlyon.seesaa.net/article/501665593.html
https://maillotlyon.bcz.com/
https://futbol2020.mystrikingly.com/blog/nottingham-forest-veut-que-dean-henderson-les-rejoigne-pour-un-contrat
http://maillotlyon365.website3.me/
https://postheaven.net/0odjdxxt12
https://dictanote.co/n/938119/
https://safechat.com/post/3169479173978169485
https://bato.to/user/1751453/maillotlyon
https://futbol2020.mystrikingly.com/blog/ac-milan-have-officially-released-home-shirt-2020-21
https://notabug.org/maillotlyon/sportsfootball/issues/1
https://codeberg.org/maillotlyon/sportfootball/issues/1
https://upverter.com/design/maillotlyon/reddevils-bayernmunich-ryan-gravenberch/
https://www.sociomix.com/diaries/entertainment/karim-benzema-refusera-de-demenager-en-arabie-saoudite-afin-de-rester-une-autre-saison-au-real-madrid/1702521710
https://tooter.in/maillotlyon/posts/111576631072017274
https://www.hahalolo.com/post/65794f3afa707f74b33359c3
https://www.debwan.com/blogs/530565/Olivier-Giroud-veut-renouer-avec-Milan
https://archive.org/details/@alamy123
https://pdfhost.io/v/N~Gfje3fT_Lionel_Messi_est_une_icne_une_lgende_et_le_bouc
https://www.edna.cz/uzivatele/maillotlyon/
https://travefy.com/discover/maillotlyon-6drw6jrxhdfq
http://maillotdefootball.mee.nu/
https://www.readawrite.com/a/3eb30cd9dadc3f4ef9677d09e53f43ba
https://c8ke.com/maillotlyon
https://www.hahalolo.com/post/65795318fa707f74b33359f9
https://www.debwan.com/blogs/530568/Andrea-D-Amico-a-salue-Nicol-Fagioli-comme-l-un
https://tooter.in/maillotlyon
https://www.sociomix.com/u/camisetaliga-chen/
https://www.sociomix.com/diaries/entertainment/liverpool-est-sur-le-point-de-signer-l-ailier-de-l-athletic-bilbao-nico-williams/1702523129
https://tooter.in/maillotlyon/posts/111576701907041253
https://www.ethiovisit.com/myplace/maillotlyon
https://upverter.com/profile/maillotlyon/
https://upverter.com/design/maillotlyon/eastleigh-fc-contre-afc-bournemout-0-6/
https://codeberg.org/maillotlyon/
https://notabug.org/maillotlyon
https://heavenarticle.com/author/maillotlyon/
https://www.railsim-fr.com/forum/index.php?/profile/39247-maillotlyon/&tab=field_core_pfield_12
https://canadahun.com/tagok/alamy123.677809/about
https://www.pixnet.net/pcard/maillotlyon/article/22935420-9fcc-11ee-9fb2-797a62ab5cbd
https://bbs.mychat.to/user.php?uid=1204067
https://boosty.to/maillotlyon/posts/3d91a6f5-2bb4-4fea-96f4-f782a8e3cab8
https://www.bandlab.com/maillotlyon
https://www.gamesfree.ca/maillotlyon
https://www.producthunt.com/@maillotlyon
https://www.szene1.at/user/maillotdefoot
https://beermapping.com/account/maillotlyon
https://tealfeed.com/maillotlyon
https://mstdn.social/@maillotlyon
willysforsale 24-05-30 16:36
´äº¯ »èÁ¦  
http://network.hu/rafemim/blog/rafe-blogja/un-expert-dechire-le-patron-d-arsenal-mikel-arteta-et-lance-un-violent-empannage-de-copie
https://hi-fi-forum.net/profile/951906
https://www.canadavisa.com/canada-immigration-discussion-board/members/maillotlyon.1177978/
https://forums.revora.net/user/1151266-maillotlyon/
https://spacehey.com/profile?id=2188748
https://annas-software.org/justwatch/test/-/issues/24
https://www.familie.pl/profil/manuepinze
https://www.shippingexplorer.net/en/user/maillotlyon/100253
https://form.jotform.com/233601554552048
https://webanketa.com/forms/6grkacsm68qkjd9h71j3ec34/
https://imageevent.com/maillotlyon/lactualitdesblessuressunderlanda
https://oredigger.net/author/maillotlyon/
https://cgscholar.com/community/profiles/user-13568-14976/updates/181543
https://www.opencode.net/-/snippets/4717
https://visual.ly/users/maillotlyon/portfolio
https://www.womenalia.com/blog/post/larsenal-de-mikel-arteta-etait-lie-a-arda-guler-mais-cest-le-real-madrid-de-carlo-ancelotti-qui-a-signe-le-milieu-offensif-lors-du-mercato-estival
https://kerbalx.com/maillotlyon
https://www.anobii.com/en/018a84d1ba2af9c66f/profile/activity
https://pensight.com/x/maillotlyon/new-question/303e37ff-f0bc-4a92-b89e-167bb90a80c9
https://www.echinacities.com/blogs/detail/2369530/14288
https://caramellaapp.com/maillotlyon/lpxqtZRHv/l-ailier-du-celtic-yang-hyun-jun
https://ticketbud.com/events/2ab1b694-a93a-11ee-8e28-42010a71702b
https://jadonsen.gitbook.io/jadonsen/
https://jsfiddle.net/Jadonsen/2Lajyquv/
https://sebangsa.com/detail/1871766
https://medcom.ru/forum/user/225360/
https://sebangsa.com/maillotlyon
https://tvmneamt.ro/author/maillotlyon/
https://sharemylesson.com/users/maillot-lyon
https://rpgplayground.com/members/camisetaligachen/profile/
https://write.as/maillotlyon/h1le-conseiller-de-joan-laporta-dit-que-lamine-yamal-et-alejandro-balde-etaient
https://www.metooo.io/e/le-veteran-du-real-madrid-donne-tort-aux-sceptiques-alors-qu-une-excellente-forme-apporte-deux-passes-decisives
https://gamma.app/public/Gareth-Southgate-denonce-les-critiques-ridicules-de-Harry-Maguire-c55t0e3sp2stqd4?mode=doc
https://www.launchora.com/story/les-emplois-nationaux-seraient-idaux-lors-du-der
https://velopiter.spb.ru/profile/104105-maillotlyon/?tab=field_core_pfield_1
https://challonge.com/zh_CN/events/maillotlyon
https://writeupcafe.com/newcastle-united-rumeurs-de-transfert-avec-les-negociations-sur-le-contrat-de-lattaquant-et-la-reclamation-de-mctominay/
https://www.surveyking.com/w/Laccord-de-sponsoring-du-nouveau-maillot-de-Man-United-est-le-plus-important-du-football
https://tl.net/forum/profile.php?user=maillotkane
https://pledgeit.org/l-athletic-club-est-convaincu-que-l-objectif-de-barcelone-restera
https://sendfox.com/maillotkane
https://micro.blog/maillotkane
https://techplanet.today/post/le-wolves-23-24-domicile-et-exterieur-et-troisieme-kit
https://personaljournal.ca/maillotkane/h1-dernieres-nouvelles-de-nottingham-forest-alors-que-lentraineur-chef-des
https://www.dibiz.com/camisetaliga2015
https://usa.life/read-blog/49120
https://gettogether.community/events/47299/un-joueur-se-rend-au-qatar-apres-un-interet-tardif-pour-le-transfert-de-crystal-palace-il-a-change-davis-la-semaine-derniere/
http://msnho.com/blog/thomas-frank-sur-neal-maupay-alors-quivan-toney-se-prepare-au-retour-lentrainement
https://techplanet.today/member/maillotkane
https://www.fitundgesund.at/profil/maillotkane
https://boersen.oeh-salzburg.at/author/maillotkane/
https://fc-baltika.ru/forum/user/44995/
https://wmart.kz/forum/user/145625/
https://3dlancer.net/profile/u1020003
https://minecraftcommand.science/profile/maillotkane
https://www.abclinuxu.cz/lide/maillotkane
https://zunal.com/introduction.php?w=791669
https://goodgame.ru/user/1626848
https://www.tractorbynet.com/forums/members/maillotkane.392036/about
https://blog.b92.net/user/248289/maillotkane/
https://because-gus.com/forums/participants/maillotkane/
http://www.trainingpages.com/author/maillotkane/
https://www.mixcloud.com/Tino14Delort/
http://www.rohitab.com/discuss/user/687295-toma16basic/
https://able2know.org/user/weah16dratini/
https://knowyourmeme.com/users/kenny22diop
https://experiment.com/users/ssteve24mounie
https://www.divephotoguide.com/user/Weah24Dratini
http://www.heromachine.com/forums/users/gini24kolo/
http://www.nfomedia.com/profile?uid=rKkSZgH
https://www.catchafire.org/profiles/2291207/
https://www.hebergementweb.org/members/tino28delort.331465/
https://muckrack.com/simon-banza/bio
https://www.fimfiction.net/user/544282/Sofiane29Dario
https://pinshape.com/users/2519212-lala29kenny
https://www.bark.com/en/gb/company/andy30delort/v9QM3/
https://openlibrary.org/people/simon01banza
https://profile.hatena.ne.jp/Lala02Irvin/
https://app.roll20.net/users/11361289/diop02sotoca-s
https://www.mifare.net/support/forum/users/gini02thomas/
http://uid.me/belinda_andy
https://whitehat.vn/members/martins05kolo.94304/about
https://440hz.my/forums/users/tino06bahoken/
http://vetstate.ru/forum/?PAGE_NAME=profile_view&UID=70462
https://www.weddingbee.com/members/tino06delort/
https://www.chaloke.com/forums/users/draxle06delorti/
https://offcourse.co/users/profile/tino07delort
https://blender3d.com.ua/forums/users/martins09kolo/
https://www.dnxjobs.de/users/Draxle09Lala
https://studiopress.community/users/weah09dratini/
http://dixxodrom.ru/forums/users/Dario09Sofiane/
http://foxsheets.statfoxsports.com/UserProfile/tabid/57/userId/114458/Default.aspx
https://www.pageorama.com/?p=ergini12draxl
https://confengine.com/user/martins-lala
https://www.lfs.net/profile/2482666
https://forum.b-zone.ro/profile/191756-stevemounie/?tab=field_core_pfield_23
https://maillotdefootpascherchine.blogfree.net/?t=6387310
http://www.milanmania.com/forum/member.php?action=profile&uid=5566
https://fulhamusa.com/members/diopsotoca.3314/
https://www.tifosibianconeri.com/forum/profile/62883-draxlergini/?tab=field_core_pfield_11
https://forums.bluemoon-mcfc.co.uk/members/delortirvin.94100/about
https://fm-base.co.uk/members/irvinsimon.698037/about
https://www.megafutbol.net/usuarios/tinodelort.4961/about
https://www.foroatletismo.com/foro/members/simonbanza.html
https://www.designfootball.com/community/my-profile/43410tinodelort
http://www.milanmania.com/forum/member.php?action=profile&uid=5573
http://www.wijzijnvoetbal.nl/forum/members/martinskolo.html
https://pfiourry-krearst-bliahl.yolasite.com/
https://inleo.io/@maillotlyon/celtic-un-adolescent-280-par-semaine-doit-tre-dchan-contre-bernardo
https://gitgud.io/dennisjohnson/lam-dep/-/issues/35
https://www.keepandshare.com/discuss3/12116/moises-caicedo-le-milieu-de-terrain-quatorien-est-l-un-des-joueurs-les-mieux-not-s-de-l-quipe
https://www.articleted.com/article/712941/249359/James-Maddison-sera-vendu-cet-ete-quel-que-soit-le-sort-de-Leicester--Newcastle-et-Manchester-City-desireux
https://articlement.com/author/maillotlyon/
https://willysforsale.com/author/maillotlyon/
https://scrapbox.io/maillotlyon/La_footballeuse_singapourienne_Danelle_Tan_realise_un_triple_pour_le_Borussia_Dortmund_lors_d'une_victoire_13-0